I was talking to Marie yesterday. Marie’s daughter, Sarah, who is 9, is very much into her gymnastics and competes regularly.
Sarah does quite well in her local and regional competitions, often winnng a medal, but she’s not nationally competitive in her age group right now. Next weekend she’s going to an invitational open competition, where all the best 9 year old gymnasts in the nation will be competing.
This dilemma for her loving mum Marie is this: “Should I encourage her competitiveness and desire to win by telling her she can do it, that I have confidence in her, and she should really go for it and she’s sure to have a good result? Or should I be more realistic and try to prepare her for disappointment by telling her that the most important thing is for her to try, to have fun, to do her best, but to remember that because of her circumstances (a new coach, emergency surgery causing time off, etc) not to get her hopes up, and be prepared to not place so high?”
I asked Marie what was the most important thing to her in raising her daughter? What was her biggest purpose?
Preparing them for life in the real world (where we regularly experience disappointments)? Nurturing their self-confidence so that they feel good about who they are? Protecting them from life’s tougher knocks?
There are two things this conversation brought to mind.
One, I hear a lot about the British culture of mediocrity, a topic of discussion especially during international individual sporting competitions –how we don’t encourage an attitude of winning, but one of trying your best. As a result (so some people say) Brits are seldom winners. The winners that DO emerge from the culture are idiosyncratic, and particularly noted for their unusual commitment and extreme will to win. Hmmm. I wonder how that unusual commitment and will to win is born? How do the exceptional performers develop their self-belief and confidence?
Second, how well do we prepare our children for the real world if we protect them from disappointment? What will happen to them once they begin to venture from the nest? Will the fledglings fly on their own? Or will they fall to the ground because they are unprepared.
I’m sure my bias is showing here. Provide love, nurturing and safety, plus good role models for self-confidence, positive thinking and taking risks (to an extent). Take care how you model fear of failure, acceptance of mediocrity or how you project your own limits onto your kids. Help them to prepare themselves the best they can for success, then let them try, and them help them learn from their results.
If Sarah doesn’t get the result she wants, then Marie can help her find a way to improve and get a better result next time.